BarkBox, Super Chewer, Bullymake or a goldendoodle box?
Four kinds of dog box, compared by what each is built for and the questions that decide which suits your doodle. Written by an interested party, so we say so.
BarkBox, Super Chewer, Bullymake or a goldendoodle box: which suits a doodle?
It depends on how your doodle chews and how much the box should know about your dog. BarkBox is a themed monthly box of toys and treats for dogs of any breed. Super Chewer is BARK's box built around tougher toys for strong chewers. Bullymake is an independent box aimed at heavy chewers. Doodles by BARK is built only for goldendoodles, picked for one named dog from its notebook. Check each company's current page before you choose.
A note before the comparison
Doodles by BARK is made by BARK, the company that also makes BarkBox and Super Chewer. We have an interest here, so this guide does not quote other boxes' prices or contents. Those change, and you should read them on each company's own page on the day you buy. What we can do is describe what each box is built for, and the questions that separate them.
What each box is built for
| Box | Built for | How it is picked |
|---|---|---|
| BarkBox (BARK) | Dogs of any breed who enjoy a monthly theme | A monthly themed selection; check their page for sizing |
| Super Chewer (BARK) | Strong chewers of any breed | A monthly selection of tougher toys; check their page for sizing |
| Bullymake | Heavy chewers of any breed | Check their current page |
| Doodles by BARK | Goldendoodles only | Picked for one named dog from the owner's notebook |
Our own row, stated plainly: five things a month, three toys and two edibles (treats or chews), $38 a month plus tax with US shipping included, US only. Skip or cancel by telling Emma in the notebook, or by email.
Seven things to compare
- Size options. Do the bands cover a 20 pound mini and a 70 pound standard properly? See our toy size table.
- Chew strength. Can you say your dog shreds everything, and does the box change because of it? Our heavy chewer guide explains why it matters.
- Food sensitivities. Can you list what your dog can't eat, and how are treats chosen around it?
- What is in each box. Count the toys and the edibles, and check whether shipping is included.
- Price per month and commitment. Month to month or prepaid? Check before you enter a card.
- Cancelling and skipping. How do you do it, and how easy is it?
- Memory. Does the box learn what your dog loved and ignored, or is every month a fresh guess?
Which to pick
- You want a fun monthly theme and your dog is a gentle player: a themed box such as BarkBox may suit.
- Your doodle destroys everything and you want toughness first: compare the chewer boxes, Super Chewer and Bullymake, on toy toughness and price.
- You want the box picked for your goldendoodle's size, chewing style and food no-gos: that is what Doodles by BARK is for. Start your dog's notebook.
For a longer checklist, see how to pick a subscription box for a goldendoodle, and for the short answer on breed-specific boxes, is there a subscription box made for goldendoodles?
FAQ
Is BarkBox worth it for a goldendoodle?
It can be, for a doodle that enjoys a variety of toys and treats and is not a heavy chewer. If your dog destroys toys or has food sensitivities, compare how each box handles those before choosing.
How is Doodles by BARK different from BarkBox?
Same company, different shape. BarkBox is a themed box for all dogs. Doodles by BARK is for goldendoodles only and is picked for one named dog from that dog's notebook: size band, chewing style, age and food no-gos.
Which dog subscription box is best for a heavy chewer?
One that changes the toys for strong chewers and sizes them up. Compare toughness, size options and price on each box's current page, and remember no toy is indestructible.
Are dog subscription boxes worth the money?
They suit dogs who enjoy variety and owners who like a monthly top-up. They suit picky or sensitive dogs only if the box lets you say what your dog likes and can't eat.
Next
A clever dog needs new things
Goldendoodles come from two of the brightest working breeds. Why mental stimulation matters for their wellbeing, how dogs get bored of the same toys, and how to keep play new.
Read →